OSG questioned over “sudden reversal” in Duterte–Dela Rosa case before the Supreme Court

OSG questioned over “sudden reversal” in Duterte–Dela Rosa case before the Supreme Court

The Office of the Solicitor General (OSG), is drawing criticism after filing an “entry of appearance” in G.R. No. 278747—the petition filed by former President Rodrigo Duterte and Senator Ronald “Bato” Dela Rosa against several government officials over the Philippines’ alleged cooperation with the International Criminal Court (ICC).

According to Atty. Israelito Torreon, legal counsel for Duterte and Dela Rosa, the record clearly shows that the OSG formally withdrew from the case last March.

In its previous submission to the Supreme Court, then-Solicitor General Menardo Guevarra stated that the OSG could not participate in any matter related to the International Criminal Court because of its firm position that the Philippines has no obligation to cooperate with the ICC after withdrawing from the Rome Statute.

The Supreme Court itself accepted and approved the OSG’s recusal on April 2, 2025—an order that remains valid and unrevoked to this day.

But for reasons still unclear, the OSG suddenly returned to the case on December 1, 2025, claiming that the Department of Justice had referred the matter back to them.

According to the petitioners’ camp, this contradicts the OSG’s earlier explanations for withdrawing and creates confusion about its true position.

In its new statement, the OSG argued that the petition is “unripe,” that Senator Dela Rosa’s concerns are speculative, and that there is no act for the Supreme Court to restrain. It also suggested that there is no proof of an ICC warrant.

But Atty. Torreon points out that this is the opposite of the OSG’s previous stance. He says that if the OSG believed the case was merely “unripe,” it could have said so in March—instead of recusing itself on the grounds of “ethical conflict” and “institutional limitations.”

He adds that the OSG’s new Comment actually confirms that government action related to the ICC is ongoing, since it admits that the DOJ is still studying all options on possible cooperation.

The OSG is also silent on reports that some government agents are assisting witnesses supposedly linked to the ICC.

For the petitioners, this silence appears to be an indirect affirmation of the DOJ’s actions—contrary to the OSG’s earlier firm position against ICC cooperation.

“Institutional positions cannot be abandoned and revived on an ad hoc basis, depending on the political weather. The OSG cannot recuse today, then resurrect itself tomorrow,” Atty. Israelito P. Torreon Legal Counsel of former Pres. Rodrigo Duterte said.

Atty. Torreon’s statement is rooted in a series of actions and documents submitted by the OSG over the past year.

When the OSG issued its recusal in March 2025, it clearly declared that its long-standing position—that the ICC has no jurisdiction over the Philippines and that the government has no obligation to cooperate—prevented it from effectively representing the government in any ICC-related case.

The Supreme Court accepted this as a formal and final withdrawal.

Thus, the OSG’s sudden return in December 2025, along with its new arguments against the petition, is viewed by the camp of Duterte and Dela Rosa as a departure from the OSG’s own principle, a contradiction of the Supreme Court’s earlier resolution, and an indication of a possible shift in institutional position driven by the current political climate.

 

Follow SMNI NEWS on Twitter