THE 2020 incident involving the beheading of teacher Samuel Patty sent shockwaves around the world.
And this year, a French court found five of the defendants, who were 14 and 15 at the time of the attack, guilty of involvement in staking out the teacher and identifying him as the attacker.
The sixth defendant, 13 at the time, was found guilty of lying about the classroom debate in comments that aggravated online anger against the teacher.
The teenagers, all students at Paty’s school, acknowledged wrongdoing and testified that they didn’t know the teacher would be killed.
One was given a six-month prison term but allowed to serve under house arrest with an electronic bracelet.
The others received special suspended sentences of between two and three years, requiring them to stay in school or jobs, along with special educative follow-up measures.
Lawyers for Paty’s family criticized the sentences as too lenient, while lawyers for the teenagers expressed relief.
In reaction to the court’s decision, Virginie Le Roy, the lawyer for Samuel Paty’s family, expressed disappointment, saying:
“A man decapitated in a street is no small thing! We’re in France, it’s 2020. And today, unfortunately, I don’t see this unanimous outburst from the judiciary. I don’t see this revolt, I don’t see this stop. I don’t see the signal to say “Be careful, we don’t do that in France,” even if you’re a minor. The hearing was disappointing. There were some good things, but also some disappointments. There were no answers for the family. I don’t think the punishment is up to scratch,” Virginie Le Roy, Lawyer of Samuel Paty’s family stated.
Mbeko Tabula, the lawyer for the young girl convicted of making false allegations, stated that the client never imagined that it would take off to such an extent, that it would tip over into such horror.
“We’re not insensitive to what the plaintiffs are going through, but on our side, my client is devastated. She never imagined that it would take off to such an extent, that it would tip over into such horror, so we need to put things into perspective. She was 13 at the time of the events, today she’s 16. It’s something that couldn’t have been anticipated. No one could have imagined for a moment that an assailant would come armed and perform this beheading. No one could!” Mbeko Tabula, Young girl’s lawyer said.
Paty’s name was disclosed on social media after he showed caricatures of Islam’s prophet during a class debate on free expression.
The publication triggered a deadly extremist massacre in the Charlie Hebdo newsroom in 2015. The five who identified Paty as the attacker were convicted of involvement in a group preparing aggravated violence.
The sixth defendant wrongly claimed Paty had asked Muslim students to leave the classroom before showing the class the cartoons, and she was convicted of making false allegations.
